Human-AI tools for concept development and expression

Human-AI tools for concept development and expression

Getting machines to support human experiences, desires, and goals requires imbuing them with representations of human situations that are beyond what can be captured through context features like APIs (e.g., Yelp, Google Awareness) and component detectors (e.g., time, location). To this end, we scaffold the creation of concept expressions: human-created translations of high-level situations like "Places to have a private conversation" into collections of context-features that machines can act on.

Creating concept expressions, however, is no easy task. Designers can fixate on early ideas, and generally struggle to comprehensively conceptualize a variety of ways that a situation can be defined. For instance, to construct a concept expression for “places to have a private conversation,” a designer might fixate on quiet places such as empty offices or quiet rooms at home, and miss entirely the alternative conception that private conversations can also happen in public spaces. They can also miss hindrances, for instance that a restaurant may be good public place for a private conversation, but not if it is too quiet, as others can easily overhear the conversation. 

To support designers reflecting on a situation at large, we propose to use AI models to support designers creating concept expressions by surfacing diverse conceptions or examples that correspond to different conceptions. While such models are hardly perfect and do contain inaccuracies, they often capture a wider span of the various ways to conceptualize a situation, and of possible hinderances that a human designer can struggle to recall. This can help designers find relevant concepts to add to an expression, either as alternative conceptions of a situation (e.g., public spaces for having a private conversation), or of hindrances that need to be considered (e.g., heard by others).  Within AI supported conception, an immediate focus is understanding the process of augmentation. While AI language models are powerful tools for suggesting ideas, creating a concept expression requires a translation of suggested examples, characteristics, and hindrances into sub-concepts and context features with clearly defined relationships to one another. It's important to gain clarity on how a suggestion is incorporated, and to support better ways of doing so in an interface.

An additional focus is on supporting designers in extending their ideas to recall further concepts and details from AI suggestions; in addition to the task of incorporation, we envision the possibility for a fruitful back-and-forth process where AI can help guide a designer's thinking in the same way that a designer would intelligently query the AI.

Human-AI tools for concept development and expression image 1

Figure 1: One obstacle is in the poor translation of AI-suggested ideas to a user's final concept expression. Our current interface supports users in highlighting relevant ideas, reflecting on them, and adding to their concept expression, but at each step some valuable information is lost.

Human-AI tools for concept development and expression image 2

Figure 2: GPT consistently helped both experienced and novice designers creating concept expressions extend their own ideas with sub-concepts and examples, and it also helped them add totally new alternative conceptions.

Prompts that were tested include: "Good places for an affordable first date", "Non-Strenuous places to enjoy nature", and "Good places to have an private emotional support conversation".

Team

Faculty

  • None

Ph.D. Students

  • None

Masters and Undergraduate Students

  • Mame Coumba Ka
  • Nuremir Babanov
  • 🎓 Alex Feng